The biggest mistake first-time founders make with an agency is getting the balance between freedom and control wrong. Give too little freedom and the agency cannot test anything. Give too much and even the best agency drifts into complacency.
Here is how to get the balance right, and what the first 90 days should look like.
Give the Agency Room to Test
A good agency needs space to try new things and come up with ideas. That needs your support, including the emotional kind. When they bring you something promising, react with energy so they keep moving in that direction. When you disagree, say so clearly.
Keep Control of Three Things
The Budget
You should always know how much is being spent each day, and why.
We build every client a cost tracker sheet, so the founder can see spend month to date, yesterday, the day before, or on any date. As a new founder you are managing cash flow, and you are probably paying for ads on a business credit card. Before scaling the budget you may even need to call your bank so the higher spend is not flagged as suspicious.
The Numbers
Meet your agency every week. Start each call by reviewing three or four metrics that capture your basic funnel:
For ecommerce and D2C: sessions, conversion rate, orders and revenue
For lead generation: spend, leads, cost per lead and qualified leads
Hypotheses and ideas belong in the call too, but only after the numbers.
The Process
Look at every metric against your baseline, your target if you have one, and a benchmark if you have one. If you are behind on sales, work out which metric is holding you back, and agree on what to try to fix it.
What the First 90 Days Should Look Like

Month One: Find the Baseline
The first month is about understanding how your metrics relate to each other: what good looks like and what average looks like for your business. Expect learning, and do not expect miracles.
Month Two: Compare and Diagnose
Now you can compare against benchmarks for businesses like yours in your country. Maybe your conversion rate from ads is well below the norm, or your click-through rate is weak. You now know where the problem is.
Month Three: Focus and Fix
When one metric is clearly behind, focus the whole agency on it for a couple of weeks until it improves. Fixing the weakest link lifts the overall result.
Do Not Demand Results Tomorrow
Avoid being the founder who says "revenue is behind, I want it on target tomorrow." That is not how it works, and those are exactly the founders who get taken advantage of by agencies promising quick fixes.
Growth is a process. Some factors are in the agency's hands and some are outside them. Your job as founder is to commit to the process of improvement.
Find the Right Distance
Get the distance right too.
Too close: asking the agency about something new every single day
Too far: disappearing for weeks so they hear from you once a month
Use the weekly call for everything that can wait. Reach out between calls only for things that are urgent and could genuinely move the needle.
Before You Sign
Make sure your business is ready. Your product or website must be ready to sell, you must be able to take payment and deliver, and leadership must agree on one clear goal for the period. Then pick an agency where a senior person leads your account, and start the weekly rhythm from week one.


