Can Agencies Fix My Failing Ad Campaigns?

How we took a beauty brand from blended ROAS of 2 to 8-10 in three months, when to fix an ad account versus rebuild it, and what to expect.

Gamal

Yes, when the problem sits inside the ad account, and most of the time it does. A failing account usually has a structure that works against itself, tracking that misleads the algorithm, or both. Fix those and the same budget starts producing very different results.

What a Failing Account Looks Like

We recently audited a beauty brand spending more than AED 100,000 a month on Meta and Google. Their paid ROAS was 1: every dirham spent on ads brought back one dirham of revenue. Across the whole business, including direct, organic and social, blended ROAS sat between 1.5 and 2.

The cause was mostly structural. On Google, where about 40% of the budget went, the brand ran 11 Shopping campaigns from the same feed with no segmentation. The same products were live in up to 10 campaigns at once, so the brand was entering the same auction against itself again and again, before facing a single competitor. 87% of Shopping spend went to products that sat in more than one campaign. One makeup kit alone spent close to AED 2,500 in a month across those campaigns without a single conversion.

There was more. The brand's own name sat as an exact-match negative keyword in an account-level list nobody checked, so brand searches were leaking to a sister company's name and converting at zero. Branded search counted every purchase twice, once through the Google Ads tag and once through the Analytics event. On Meta, the top-spending campaign was optimising for landing page views, and campaigns ran on three different attribution settings, so none of them could be compared. We cover the full audit in How Agencies Find and Fix Underperforming Ads.

Fix It or Rebuild It?

We fix an account when its foundation is sound: a structure that is simple, direct and able to scale. In that case the account carries learning history worth keeping, and we use every bit of leverage it gives us.

We rebuild when campaigns were created for the sake of it. Too many campaigns, too many ad groups, no clear logic, nothing that could scale without getting more complicated. Patching that kind of account keeps the waste alive. Starting over costs little, and what you build replaces it for years.

The beauty brand was a rebuild.

The Three Changes That Moved It

Simplifying a messy campaign structure into a few clear groups
  1. One Shopping structure instead of eleven. We closed the overlapping campaigns and built one catch-all campaign, with top-selling products and categories split into their own campaigns and removed from the catch-all. New winners that surface in the catch-all get the same treatment, so no product ever bids against itself again.

  2. Weekly search-term reviews. A keyword is what you bid on; a search term is what people actually typed. Reviewing search terms every week, adding the good ones and excluding the irrelevant ones, is where most of the hidden waste in search accounts lives.

  3. A full clean-up of negative lists, at account and campaign level, including stopping Shopping ads from competing with branded search on the brand's own name.

The 10-minute fixes went in alongside: one primary purchase action on Google so bidding saw real conversions, and one attribution setting across Meta.

We did not scale the budget straight away. We waited until the new structure showed stronger, consistent signals, then increased spend.

The Result

Within three months, blended ROAS went from 1.5 to 2 up to between 8 and 10, depending on the month, the promotions running and the budget. That is the whole business's revenue against all ad spend, on Meta, Google and everything else, measured the same way before and after.

How We Tell a Founder

Plainly. We show what the current structure is costing, what we would change first, second and third, and what that should do for revenue in the first months.

Then we make the decision reversible: if the new setup does not work, we can go back to the old one. We have never had to. The offer is there so a founder can say yes knowing there is nothing to lose. If the old account was built by an in-house team or a previous agency, the same rule applies. The numbers do the talking, and nobody needs to be blamed for the founder to move forward.

When Ads Are Not the Problem

Sometimes the account is fine and the sales still do not come, because the problem sits on the website, in the offer or further down the funnel. An honest agency will tell you that too, and show you why. See Why Your Current Ads Aren't Converting.