How Agencies Find and Fix Underperforming Ads

What a real ad account audit finds, from campaigns bidding against themselves to double-counted sales, and the order we fix it in.

Gamal

Underperforming ads rarely have one cause. They usually have a dozen small ones, each set up by someone at some point and never checked again. Finding them takes a full audit of the ad accounts, the tracking and the feed. Fixing them takes a clear order, starting with what costs the most.

What a Real Audit Finds

Here is what we found in a recent audit of a beauty brand spending more than AED 100,000 a month on Meta and Google.

On Google, which took about 40% of the budget:

  • 11 Shopping campaigns with no feed segmentation. The same products were live in up to 10 campaigns at once, so the brand was bidding against itself. 87% of Shopping spend went to products sitting in more than one campaign, and Google, not the brand, decided which campaign served each one.

  • Sales counted twice. Branded search had two primary purchase actions, the Google Ads tag and the Analytics purchase event. The campaign optimised on inflated numbers.

  • The brand's own name blocked. Someone had added the brand name as an exact-match negative keyword in an account-level list. Because it sat at list level, nobody saw it. Brand budget drifted to searches for a sister company, from people checking whether the two were related. Those searches never converted.

  • A Ramadan offer still running five months after Ramadan. It was the top-spending asset in its campaign.

On Meta:

  • Optimising for the wrong thing. Between April and August, spend tripled, landing page views rose eight times and purchases only tripled. The top-spending campaign was set to maximise landing page views, and it did exactly that.

  • A broken destination. The conversion location was the website, but the ads pointed to an app that was never connected.

  • HTTP links on four live ads. Every click went through a redirect before landing, putting tracking parameters at risk.

  • No checkout step in the funnel. The site tracked product views, add to cart and purchase, with nothing in between. There were 8,800 add-to-carts and 270 purchases: about 3% of carts became orders, and there was no way to see where the rest dropped off. Meta had nothing closer to the sale to optimise on.

  • Three attribution settings across ten campaigns. Four counted sales up to seven days after a click or one day after a view, three counted one day after a click, and three used Apple's SKAdNetwork. The best performer was on the strictest setting. None of them could be compared fairly.

  • Out-of-stock products advertised, and product prices in the catalogue that did not match the landing page.

The Order We Fix It In

An analyst working through an ad account audit

You cannot fix everything on day one, so we start with what costs the most money.

1. The Google Shopping structure. Nearly all of the Shopping budget was bidding against itself. We replace overlapping campaigns with one catch-all, split the top-selling products and categories into their own campaigns, and use feed labels so money goes to what performs. New winners from the catch-all get split out the same way. This takes weeks to do properly.

2. The tracking. One primary purchase action on Google. It takes about ten minutes, and it means Google bids on real conversions instead of believing it is doing better than it is.

3. One attribution setting on Meta, and no more landing-page-view optimisation. Every campaign on the same window, so they can be compared side by side. If you want upper-funnel campaigns, optimise for add to cart at most. A landing page view on its own means very little.

Then the rest: the checkout event, the HTTPS links, the stock and price sync in the feed, the negative lists and the expired Ramadan asset.

What Changes in the First Month

Decisions start to rest on accurate data. When every campaign uses the same rules, you can finally see which ones work, which messages land with customers and where the next dirham should go. Results follow from there. For this brand, they followed fast: see Can Agencies Fix My Failing Ad Campaigns?.

Why Nobody Caught It

None of these problems was dramatic on its own. Each was a setting someone chose once and nobody revisited. That is the case for a fresh audit whenever results stall, and for an agency that checks the settings under the dashboard as well as the dashboard itself.