How to Choose the Right Marketing Agency

How to choose a performance marketing agency: judge the people on your account, the incentives in the deal, the tools included and how they think about growth.

Gamal

Choose a marketing agency by the people who will work on your account, the incentives in the deal, and the way they think about growth. The agency's name, size and award shelf tell you very little about any of those.

I have chosen agencies as a client for most of my career, including at GMG, a multi-brand, multi-market retailer where agency selection was a serious process. Now I run one. Here is the method I would use if I were a founder choosing today.

Take Your Time With the Evaluation

At GMG we did not pick agencies in a 30-minute call. We looked at:

  • How the agency thinks about growth

  • Case studies of similar work and what drove the results

  • What forecast they expected for our business, and why

  • What they found missing in our setup, essentially a short audit of our business

We reviewed all of it and wrote down what was good, what was bad and why. A founder does not need a procurement team to do the same. You need a few sharp questions and the patience to test the answers.

Judge the People, Not the Brand

Meeting the people who will actually run the account

The most overlooked step is checking who will actually work on your account.

An agency's reputation is often built on a team that has since left. Maybe they did brilliant work five years ago. That tells you nothing about the people who will run your ads next month. Ask the agency to name the people who will be allocated to you, then do your diligence on each of them:

  • What have they personally worked on?

  • Have they grown a business like yours, or one with a similar challenge?

  • If not, how do they think about growth?

They do not need to have worked in your exact niche. They do need to be people you would trust with your ad budget.

Be Wary of Size

When an agency tells you it has 50, 100 or 200 people, treat it as a warning sign. At that size, the agency has become a brand in its own right, and the senior people sell while juniors deliver. You end up paying for someone else's learning.

Look at the Incentives

Ask how the agency gets paid and what that rewards. A fixed retainer is standard in the GCC and works for many businesses. If you are a founder trying to grow fast, look for a partner willing to put skin in the game, with a fee tied to the sales they bring in instead of the budget they spend.

The purpose of marketing is to make money. If the agency does its job and you do yours, the money should come. So ask them directly: why should the founder carry all the risk?

Check What the Fee Includes

Every agency now talks about AI and tools. Many then charge extra to use them, to build them or to roll out each new feature that hits the market. Make sure your deal covers almost everything related to performance and growth, so you are not paying a new invoice every time the agency gets a new gadget.

Test How They Think

Ask about problems close to yours. How do they think about lead qualification? How do they scale a winning campaign? What would they do if a competitor started bidding on your brand name?

Listen for reasoning, not a recited best practice. Good answers sound like someone who has been in the situation, has seen the typical answer fail, and knows what to do next.

Watch for Complexity

Ask to see an example account structure. Some agencies build deliberately complicated setups that make their work hard to review. Simple structures scale faster, and Google says the same in its own guidance: "Simpler structures with consolidated, tightly-themed setups unlock better performance." If an agency cannot explain why its structure is complicated, it should not be.

A Shortlist That Works

The right agency will:

  • Name the people on your account and let you check their experience

  • Offer a deal with real incentives tied to your growth

  • Include its tools in the fee

  • Explain its thinking in plain language

  • Keep the account simple enough for you to review

Pick the one that passes all five, even if it is the smallest name on your list.