If you only have 30 minutes with each agency on your shortlist, ask about four things: price and incentives, the people on your account, the tools they bring, and how they think about growth. The answers to those questions will separate a good agency from a bad one faster than any credentials deck.
Here are the questions I would ask, and the answers that should make you walk away.
Questions About Price and Incentives
How do you get paid, and what does that reward?
A retainer, a percentage of ad spend or a share of results all reward different behaviour. A percentage of ad spend rewards spending more. A share of sales rewards growing your business.
Walk away if they cannot explain how their fee connects to your results.
Would you take some risk on my business?
Paid marketing exists to make money. If the agency does its job and you do yours, revenue should follow. A confident agency should be willing to tie part of its fee to sales it brings in.
Walk away if the answer makes clear that you, the founder, will carry all the risk.
Questions About People

Who exactly will work on my account?
Get names and roles. Then ask about each person's experience, the brands they have worked on and the results they have personally delivered.
Walk away if they answer with the agency's headcount or awards. A big team is often where juniors learn on your budget.
How much time will the senior person spend on my account?
At many agencies, the senior person who pitched you spends an hour a month on your account once you sign.
Walk away if the senior involvement ends after the pitch.
Have they worked on something like my business?
They do not need your exact niche. They do need to have solved a similar problem, or be able to explain clearly how they would approach it.
Questions About Tools and Technology
What tools and AI do you use, and are they included?
Good agencies now build tools that make their work faster and better: competitor intelligence, feed management, tracking, reporting, creative production.
Walk away if every tool turns out to be a paid add-on. You do not want an invoice every time a new feature reaches the market.
Questions About Thinking
How do you think about growth for a business like mine?
Ask about a real problem you face. For a lead business, ask how they think about lead qualification. For ecommerce, ask how they would scale a winning product.
Walk away from textbook answers. Average marketers recite platform best practice. Strong ones explain what they would do in your situation and why.
What would you do if it did not work?
This is the question I use when I hire. Everyone has a plan for when things go right. Listen to how they think when the plan fails.
What do you see missing in our setup?
A serious agency will have looked at your ads, your site or your tracking before the call and will have spotted something.
What the Answers Should Add Up To
After three calls, you should know:
Which agency has incentives that match yours
Who would actually run your account, and whether they are senior
What tools come with the fee
Who thinks most clearly about your specific problem
If an agency is vague on any of these in a 30-minute call, it will be vague for the next 12 months.


